The scope of ordre public with regard to fundamental procedural principles is of great importance to arbitration law and is regularly the subject of state court decisions. If an arbitral award violates domestic or international ordre public, it may be set aside by state courts under Sec. 1059 (2) No. 2 lit. b Code of Civil Procedure ("ZPO"). The Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt has now decided that the publication of a dissenting opinion by one arbitrator is not sufficient grounds for setting aside the arbitral award (Order dated 6 November 2026 – 32 Sch 3/26; press release can be found here: Veröffentlichung eines Sondervotums rechtfertigt nicht Aufhebung des Schiedsspruchs | Hessen Ordentliche Gerichtsbarkeit). It departed from principles it had established in an obiter dictum in an order dated 16 January 2020 – 26 Sch 14/18, BeckRS 2020, 4606.
In the underlying dispute, the applicant sought to set aside an arbitral award in which it was ordered to pay EUR 1.25 million in damages to respondent. The arbitration proceedings concerned respondent's termination of a distribution agreement for dialysis machines. The petitioner unsuccessfully sought damages or specific performance and was ordered to pay damages in response to the respondent's counterclaim. One of the three arbitrators issued a dissenting opinion in which he expressed a differing view on several items of the arbitral award. The applicant alleged a breach of the confidentiality of deliberations and argued that the arbitral award should be set aside due to a violation of the ordre public.
Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt issued an obiter dictum in 2020:
Ordre public is violated if the arbitral tribunal has disregarded a party's fundamental procedural right and the arbitral award rests on that violation. Although enshrined in Sec. 46 DRiG (Judges Act), the principle of confidentiality of deliberations also applies to arbitrators. The admissibility of a dissenting opinion in arbitration proceedings has not yet been expressly regulated by law. The 26th Civil Senate of the Higher Regional Court held in 2020 that
1. confidentiality of deliberations constitutes a fundamental procedural right within the meaning of ordre public, such that it is not subject to the parties' disposition in arbitration proceedings;
2. the subsequent publication of a dissenting opinion violates the confidentiality of deliberations.
The 32nd Civil Senate of the Higher Regional Court concurred that the confidentiality of deliberations must be observed in arbitration proceedings. In all other respects, it departed from the view of the 26th Civil Senate:
1. A dissenting opinion published after the conclusion of the arbitration proceedings is not incompatible enough with the confidentiality of deliberations as to justify setting aside the arbitral award. Dissenting opinions also exist within the state court system, such as at the Federal Constitutional Court under Sec. 30 (2) BVerfGG. Furthermore, the dissenting opinion was submitted after the award was rendered. The protective purpose of the confidentiality of deliberations had already been fulfilled. While the publication of a dissenting opinion may provide grounds for challenging the decision of the tribunal itself, such a form of arbitral self-review is nonetheless justified.
2. In any event, there is no causal link between the procedural violation and the decision rendered, since the publication of the dissenting opinion occurs retrospectively.
The 32nd Civil Senate expressly included the draft legislation on the modernization of arbitration law in its deliberations. Sec. 1054a ZPO is intended to clarify the future admissibility of dissenting opinions in arbitration proceedings.
The recent decision by the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt reinforces arbitration as an alternative to civil litigation in state courts. As a voluntary dispute resolution process, arbitration relies on transparency and comprehensibility to establish its legitimacy. Dissenting opinions can strengthen the parties' confidence in the arbitrators' independence by demonstrating that a minority view was heard and seriously considered. Furthermore, this expands the already greater procedural flexibility of arbitration compared to state court proceedings.
At the same time, the decision prevents a potential attempt to jeopardize the arbitral award through a possible setting aside in state courts by issuing a dissenting opinion. The advantage of arbitration, reaching a final and binding decision in a single instance without the risk of lengthy appellate proceedings, remains intact.
It remains to be seen whether the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) will issue a final ruling on this matter or whether the legislature will first provide the urgently needed clarity through Sec. 1054a ZPO.
In practice, caution should continue to be exercised regarding dissenting opinions in arbitral awards for the time being. Until the admissibility of such opinions is definitively clarified, it may be advisable for the parties to expressly exclude the issuance of dissenting opinions in the arbitration agreement.