YOUR
Search

    23.01.2022

    Delivery cyclists have a right to a bike and a mobile phone


    Judgment of the Federal Labour Court of 10 November 2021 in Case No. 5 AZR 334/21

     

    You see them everywhere, tearing through the city on their bikes while glancing at their smartphones: delivery cyclists delivering an evening meal or the weekly shopping in huge backpacks. The Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, BAG) has now held that employers must make available to the delivery riders the work tools necessary for the riders to deliver delicacies such as pizza or burgers.

     

    Facts of the case

     

    The case was brought against an employer of bike courier riders who deliver food and drinks from various restaurants. The employment contracts took the form of general terms and conditions and required the cyclists to provide their own bicycle and use their own mobile phone. For each hour of work, the cyclists received a EUR 0.25 credit that could be used for bike repairs at specific repair shops. An employee brought a claim before the court and demanded that the employer make available a roadworthy bicycle and a suitable smartphone for his contractually agreed activities. He argued that it was the responsibility of the employer to provide the necessary tools. The employer responded that its employees already had their own bicycle and mobile telephone anyway. Any disadvantage from using their own was compensated by the statutory option to reimburse expenses and to provide credit for repairs.

     

    The judgment

     

    The BAG decided in favour of the employee: the requirement for the cyclist to use his own bike and smartphone unreasonably disadvantaged the Claimant in contravention of § 307 (2) No. 1 and the first sentence of § 307 (1) of the Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB) and is therefore ineffective. The contractual provisions in question meant that the employer did not have to pay the procurement and operational costs to the detriment of the employee, nor bear the cost risk associated with wear and tear, loss, or damage to the essential work tools. This was contrary to one of the basic concepts of the working relationship, which requires the employer to provide the essential tools for the performance of the agreed activities and to ensure that the tools functioned effectively. In the Court’s view, the resulting disadvantage was also not sufficiently compensated in the present case. The reimbursement of expenses, as required under statute, does not constitute appropriate compensation as there was no contractual provision.  In addition, the employee did not have free access to the budget for repairs. The employee therefore has a right, in accordance with § 611a (1) of the BGB, to be provided with a bicycle and a smartphone that are suitable for the performance of the agreed activities.

     

    Consequences for practice

     

    The judgment is designed to ensure that the minimum wage levels imposed by law cannot be undermined. Employees, especially those who are only paid close to the minimum wage for their work, cannot be asked to make further sacrifices with their assets to be able to perform their work. The employer must make the necessary tools available to the employee.>

     

    Practical tip

     

    The judgment clarifies that employers cannot escape their obligations to bear the procurement and operational costs for necessary work tools. However, the Court indicated that it would be possible to pay appropriate financial compensation instead of providing the tools. This gives employers sufficient contractual leeway to find an appropriate solution.

     

    Regina Holzer

    ADVANT Beiten advises ENGIE Germany on the sale of Solarimos' nationwide tenant electricity portfolio to Einhundert Energie
    Freiburg/Berlin, 15 April 2025 – The international law firm ADVANT Beiten advise…
    Read more
    ADVANT Pulse No. 4: Your Labour & Employment News
    As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to transform workplaces and is becomin…
    Read more
    ADVANT Beiten Advises Banyan Software on Acquisition of FoxInsights
    Freiburg, 10 February 2025 - The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has provid…
    Read more
    ADVANT Beiten Advises Shareholders of HECHT Contactlinsen GmbH on Sale of their Shares to Novum Capital
    Freiburg, 21 November 2024 – The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has provid…
    Read more
    [Translate to English:]
    ADVANT Beiten Advises Amphenol on Acquisition of Luetze Group
    Berlin, 16 October 2024 - The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has advised t…
    Read more
    ADVANT Beiten Advises the Herder Publishing Group on the Expansion of its Online Products for the Nursery Market
    Freiburg, 6 August 2024 – The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has advised H…
    Read more
    ADVANT Beiten Advises Aesculap on Sale of TETEC AG to the Canadian Octane Group
    Dusseldorf, 26 June 2024 – The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has provided interdisciplinary advice to Aesculap AG, a subsidiary of the B. Braun group seated in Melsungen, Germany, on the sale of its…
    Read more
    ADVANT Beiten Advises COMEM Group on Acquisition of Weidmann Technologies Deutschland
    Berlin, 2 April 2024 – The international law firm ADVANT Beiten has comprehensively advised COMEM S.p.A., headquartered in Italy, on the acquisition of all shares in Weidmann Technologies Deutschland GmbH,…
    Read more
    Adacta and ADVANT Beiten Advise EBARA on the Acquisition of a Business Division of SKF
    Munich, 24 July 2023 - The international commercial law firm ADVANT Beiten has advised EBARA Pumps Europe S.p.A. (EPE), part of the Japanese EBARA Corporation (EBARA), on the acquisition of the business di…
    Read more